{{status_msg}}

Home Prices Are Softening. What Buyers Can Negotiate Now

Posted:

November 17th

  • Share on Facebook

For over three years, the price of the average American home consistently surpassed that of the previous year. However, this trend has now come to an end. Recent national data for October indicates that the median sale price of homes has dipped, marking the first annual drop since spring 2023. Concurrently, the total number of homes available for purchase has reached its highest level since early 2020, pending sales have plummeted to a decade-low, outside the initial pandemic phase, and nearly 20% of homes on the market have seen a price reduction.

Despite this shift, financing remains more costly. The current average rate on a 30-year fixed mortgage has surged back into the mid-7% range after a temporary respite. Consequently, while buyers may find themselves in a more favorable negotiating position, many households still face challenges with monthly payments.

This unique situation presents a rare opportunity. With sellers encountering fewer offers and extended listing durations, the proposed prices and terms often become merely a starting point. If you are on the lookout for a home this winter, here are some factors that might be negotiable and how you can approach these discussions with your representative and lender.

Understanding the significance of a slight price drop

A national decrease of less than half a percent isn't indicative of a market collapse, nor does it suggest that all areas are experiencing falling prices. Some high-end coastal markets with very low inventory continue to see substantial appreciation, while several major metropolitan areas in the South and West have experienced declines of several percentage points compared to last year. The specifics of your local market hold more weight than the national average.

The national figures indicate a shift in the balance of power. With more homes languishing unsold and listings vying for a dwindling number of buyers, sellers are becoming increasingly amenable to discussing terms. This flexibility can manifest in the sale price or potentially in other sale conditions.

Price negotiation is just one component

While many buyers concentrate solely on the price, in a high-interest environment, factors such as monthly payments and upfront cash requirements can heavily influence affordability. A reduction in price by a few thousand may result in only a slight decrease in your mortgage. However, reallocating that same sum in other areas can make a more substantial impact on your budget. In a slower market, typical points for negotiation include:

  • A lower purchase price compared to the listed amount
  • A seller contribution towards closing costs
  • Completion of repairs before closing, or provision of a credit instead
  • Seller assistance in reducing your mortgage rate
  • A closing date or move-in schedule that matches your needs
  • Inclusions of items like appliances or window treatments with the home

Your agent can provide insights into the responses of local sellers, helping you identify which points to emphasize in your offer. The key is to focus on what's most beneficial to you rather than requesting every possible concession.

Selling credits can alleviate closing costs

Closing expenses typically account for several percentage points of the loan amount, in addition to your down payment. For many first-time buyers, gathering this cash proves to be challenging. A credit from the seller can alleviate some of these costs, allowing you to bring less cash to the closing.

It is crucial to be aware of boundaries. Different loan programs limit the amount sellers can contribute, often ranging between 3% to 9% of the sale price based on the loan type and the size of your down payment. Also, a credit cannot exceed your actual closing expenses. Consult with your lender early to understand what your specific loan allows, ensuring any requests you include in your offer comply with these guidelines.

Understanding the mechanics of a rate buydown

With interest rates rising above 7%, one of the most valuable concessions a seller can offer is assistance with your interest rate. There are two primary types:

A permanent buydown involves paying discount points at closing to reduce your mortgage rate for the loan's entirety. Each point costs 1% of the loan amount, and the rate reduction varies depending on the lender and market conditions. If you intend to maintain the loan for an extended period, a permanent buydown can prove beneficial.

A temporary buydown makes your initial monthly payments lower for the first year or two. In a standard arrangement, the interest rate is reduced by two percentage points during the first year and by one percentage point during the second, reverting to the original rate thereafter. For instance, with a $350,000 30-year loan at approximately 7.34%, your monthly principal and interest payment would be about $2,409. After applying that temporary buydown, your payment in the first year would drop to around $1,952, and in the second year, it would be approximately $2,176, before returning to the original figure in year three. This arrangement may cost just over $8,000 to set up, which a seller might prefer to cover instead of reducing the price equivalently.

A temporary buydown doesn't offer a long-lasting solution. You need to be ready for the full payment once the discount period concludes, and lenders generally qualify you based on the complete rate. Should rates decrease in the future, refinancing might be a possibility, though no one can guarantee when or if that will happen.

Don't forgo the inspection to appear more attractive

In previous competitive markets, many buyers chose to waive inspections or limit their requests to secure a winning bid. In a slower market, there's less urgency to relinquish these crucial protections. Conducting a thorough home inspection is essential for assessing the state of the roof, HVAC systems, plumbing, electrical wiring, and foundation before finalizing your purchase.

If the inspection reveals any issues, your agent can guide you in determining whether to request repairs, a price adjustment, or a credit. Credits may often be easier to navigate than seller-managed repairs, as they allow you to control the choice of contractor and the specifics of the work done. However, the most appropriate option will depend on the nature of the issue and your loan's stipulations.

Prepare your financing in advance

Having strong negotiation power is ineffective without solid financing. When reviewing multiple offers, sellers typically favor buyers who seem most likely to complete the sale. Before you begin your home search, aim for a comprehensive pre-approval rather than a mere prequalification; be clear about your maximum comfortable monthly payment in addition to your loan limit, and compare estimates from different lenders. Inquire with each lender about their stance on seller credits or buydowns to avoid any unexpected surprises later on.

Important questions to address with your agent

  • What is the average time homes in this area remain on the market, and how frequently do prices get adjusted?
  • Would a reduction in price, a credit for closing costs, or a rate buydown provide the most assistance to my budget?
  • How do the condition and history of this particular home influence my negotiation strategy?
  • What contingencies should I retain in my offer to safeguard my interests?

The final takeaway

A softening market does not equate to inexpensive buying options, especially with rising mortgage rates. However, this environment affords informed buyers greater leeway to negotiate terms that suit their financial situations. With robust financing, a clear understanding of your priorities, and the support of your agent and lender, you may be able to achieve more favorable conditions than what buyers could hope for a year or two ago.

Rewritten using AI

Private Advisory

Let’s discuss your next
Colorado move.

Whether you are buying, selling, relocating, or evaluating an investment, Jackie Yost Team brings calm, strategic guidance to the process.

Start A Conversation
FOLLOW US
Floating Icon